Guide · Second opinion

Getting a second opinion on your financial advisor

A second opinion checks whether your plan, fees and investments still serve you. It doesn't mean firing your advisor. It means making sure the advice holds up.

Five questions to answer

  1. What am I paying in total, as a percentage and in dollars?
  2. Is my advisor a fiduciary at all times, or only sometimes?
  3. How has my portfolio done against a simple index mix with the same risk?
  4. Do any products I own pay my advisor a commission?
  5. Does my plan reflect my current goals, taxes and timeline?

Red flags

  • You can't get a clear answer on fees.
  • Surrender charges or annuities you don't understand.
  • Lots of trading with no explanation.
  • No written plan or no review in over a year.

An independent review, no sales pitch

Atrium's Second Opinion specialist reviews your statements, totals your all-in fees, and lists the questions to bring to your advisor. Atrium has nothing to sell you. See also Atrium vs. a financial advisor.

Common questions

When should I get a second opinion on my financial advisor?
Get one when fees are unclear, performance lags a simple benchmark for several years, recommendations seem to favor products your advisor sells, or before a big irreversible decision like an annuity, a pension election or selling a business.
What should I bring to a second opinion review?
Recent account statements, your advisor's fee disclosure (Form ADV Part 2 for registered advisors), any insurance or annuity contracts, your last tax return, and your written financial plan if you have one.
Is a second opinion free?
Many advisory firms offer free second opinions, often hoping to win your business. Flat-fee planners charge a set price. Software like Atrium gives an independent review without a sales pitch.
How do I check what I'm really paying?
Add the advisory fee, the fund expense ratios, and any commissions or insurance charges. A 1% advisory fee plus 0.5% in fund costs is 1.5% a year, which compounds into a large amount over decades.

Atrium Wealth Council® is educational planning software, not a registered investment advisor, tax preparer, attorney, or insurance broker.